State of the Sharks...
Line changes, but no revelations on meeting - The San Jose Mercury News Sharks Hockey Blog -:
so far, what went on in the room is indeed staying in the room.
The Sharks were back on the ice for a light game-day skate this morning and afterward, players were glad to talk in generalities about their two-hour meeting Friday, but when it came to specifics, players would give you a smile but no real information.
And that includes captain Patrick Marleau, who left after yesterday’s session without talking to a reporter.
“It’s good to get some things out in the open and talk about them,” said Marleau, who explained that he had to leave right after the meeting to get his brother to a doctor’s appointment.
I suppose I should cut Marleau some slack for the doctor's appointment, but...
Ya know, I've been supportive of Marleau as Captain, pushing back on some of the critics (on blogs and at the arena). But to be honest, he's disappointed this year.
And now, after a two hour team meeting at a critical point in the season, he ducks the press, while Mike Grier, Joe Thornton, Jeremy Roenick and Evgeny (not John) Nabokov stand up and take the lumps. He clearly could have at least taken two minutes to say "gotta run, but wanted to say...." -- something.
Color me disappointed -- again.
A while back I got floated one of those friends of a friend of a friend rumor which I've sat on, because you really can't judge them and when you have only one source, how do you judge them? I'm not a fan of blabbing every little fan-boy fantasy that comes along, so I've always tried to learn what sources are trustworthy and what rumors to pay attention to. This one? No basis whatsoever, except that I keep thinking about it and feeling that it seems to fit the situation pretty well.
And this comes from -- emphasizing how tenuous this is -- a friend who had a friend who met up with someone on Caltrain before the game, someone coming down from the city for the game who had a specific european accent. He claimed to be an old school chum who'd flown in to spend time with his buddy, who happens to play hockey for the Sharks. (excuse me for not naming nationalities, accents or names... No sense getting people involved indirectly). That person claimed that there was a lot of unhappiness in the locker room around Marleau -- and also that Marleau himself was unhappy.
The unhappiness with Marleau came from his being a new daddy; he was really enjoying being a new daddy -- enough so that he wasn't focussing on hockey or the team enough. Look at Marleau's home and away numbers; they unfortunately can be interpreted at something like this. Marleau hasn't STUNK -- but to mean, far too often he simply doesn't seem to have his head or heart in the game in San Jose. One could argue that getting on the road and in a hotel room gets him away from the home environment, and gets him back in his routine and focussed on the game -- hence his much strong road play.
And as to Marleau not being happy here? he doesn't like being in the shadow of Thornton, not being 2nd dog.
Take them for what you will. Or won't. I've had trouble believing that second one -- if he was unhappy, why did he sign the long-term deal to stay here?
But the home distraction? I have trouble rejecting it out of hand, not based on what I've been seeing. I know some fans love to play the "they make a lot of money, how dare they not perform?" game, but the fact that someone signs a contract for a good chunk of money doesn't mean the Sharks lock up their humanity in a box in a safe somewhere. The reality is, hockey players play through stuff routinely that would put most fans mewling and puking under their desks. It can be frustrating to us when a player proves himself -- so human -- but that doesn't make them not human. No "slab of meat" treatment here. And I can sympathize with someone who's got a new kid at home and that becomes a bit of a center of their life.
But he's had enough time -- and criticism - by now to figure out how to merge his home life into his work life and make them both work. And if this IS the problem, he hasn't done it. If it's not the problem, I have to wonder what is, because something is. His road numbers indicate he CAN play well, his home numbers indicate he simply isn't. So what now?
And it's pretty clear that he's captain; but he's not leading this team. this isn't necessarily a terrible thing. I don't believe a captain has to be loud and noisy and throw things (and people) around the locker room -- hell, we had that with Owen Nolan, and look how well that turned out. Marleau is more a captain in the style of Yzerman or Sakic, quiet but speaking at key moments, and leading by example on and off the ice. Except, unfortunately, he's not leading by example on the ice. he's one of the problems. And now leadership of this team has migrated -- to Grier, to Thornton, to Roenick, and to Nabokov.
So where does that leave Marleau?
I don't know what was said in that locker room among the players, but I can make guesses. More importantly, I think I know the gist of the Doug Wilson chat BEFORE the players chat. That was likely the "we believe this is the right team, but if you guys don't fix yourselves, we'll have to make changes to fix you" speech. One can only imagine which players he was staring at while saying it. you can bet it wasn't Grier, or Nabokov, or thornton, or Roenick...
Maybe Marleau needs a change of scenery. Maybe he just needed a kick in the butt by his Gm and his teammates (hell, he's not alone. Matt Carle, Kyle McLaren -- please bend over and start wincing; I'll cut Cheechoo slack because it was clear he wasn't healthy, even before he admitted he was hurt). And they aren't alone -- this team braincramps too regularly at key moments, and it's a group effort. It's almost as if they believe how good they are, and therefore mentally sit back thinking it's going to be easy. Nobody's easy in this league -- just look at the Coyotes now.
It'll be interesting to see how they react tonight. The Sharks have shown signs of coming around, but the consistency and committment still aren't there reliably enough. Better != Good, and even good isn't good enough yet. What I am convinced is if they don't show that they're coming around, and do so like starting in about three hours, then Wilson's going to have a short trigger and start looking to re-arrange the deck chairs. And you can bet he won't try to shake up the team by trading Patzold....
The good news is this team has played pretty well; over.500 and just under .500 at home -- but while it's avoided digging a hole so there's nothing to climb out of, it's not come close to playing to potential. Either they find that potential fast, or Doug Wilson will do something to help them find it. THAT's why they had a 2 hour meeting the other day -- and boy, I'll bet it was fun to be in...
(not!)
Recent Comments